Would you let your child read Doreamon books?

macademia

Lately I found Doreamon books in my house. Rupa2nya my std 2 girl yg start beli. She's hooked with Doraemon books and her std 1 brother is following suit.

Bila MAc tgk buku Doraemon tu, I find the the BM language used is atrocious!. Although benda ni macam comic book and not for serious reading, but mac takut budak2 ni terinfluence with BM yg entah apa2 tu.

Would u let yr children read buku Doraemon? MAc rasa kesian pulak nak get rid of the books. Sebab nampak sangat they like the cartoon. Their elder sisters suruh buang aje.....

Would you?

Note  : FYI they also read other story books.

RedAlert

Personally, I don't mind my kids baca komik doraemon as long as they read other books / better quality reading materials. Biasalah budak2, kadang-kadang yang merapu-rapu tu yang interesting. In fact, in a way, it's even better kalau diaorang aware how bad the language is... at least they can differentiate which is wrong or right ... or which is cool or uncool (of course, yang pelik tulah cool kan!)

Ingat lagi dulu masa majalah gila-gila baru keluar, my dad memang haramkan kitaorang adik beradik beli baca majalah tu tapi dalam diam-diam kitaorang baca jugak... selalunya kat rumah org lah bila ada peluang. These things susah nak kawal. I guess as long as it doesn't get out of hand, it should be ok kot.

tina^^

masa kecit dulu my mom mmg ristrict me and siblings dari beli buku2 mcm citer pak pandir la, pehtu lebai malang la, and majalah2 hiburan cam URTV, komik gila gila tue sumer. buku2 ceta dan majalah2 lain takper, cam dewan bahasa la aper tue sumer.

mmg rumah kitorang tadek buku mcm tue. my mom TAK KASIK BELI DAN BACA.

me, out of curiosity, tetap semunyik2 baca kawan2 lain punyer....hihihi....and i find them interesting jugak...cuma in terms of lenggok bahasa...mmg out la. tp, me rasa tadekla menggugat sgt my pemahaman n penulisan masa tue....oklaa..

my kid's time nanti...ermm......i 50-50 kot... larang tidak, galak pon tidak. tp kalau dier nak baca...i akan screen thru laa aperkemendenyer isi dalam tue....kalau for light n ez entertainment tak ngarot2 masok yg lucah2 tak senonoh ker aper....ermm...ku beri jeklah....sbb knowing me, kalau tak bagik pon, me akan smuyik2 cari nak tau sdirik. kotla my kids nanti ada perangai camtue....haha

ajasu

tina, my parents especially my dad is like ur mom
he prevented us from buying or reading such comics n mags macam gila2 tuh
penah one time he learned out that my brothers keep the whole series of dragon ball, and he throw it away - satu guni penuh plus other comic
bile kitorg gi tgk kt tmpt buang tuh dh ilang guni tuh...ada org amik kot
mmg kitorg kumpul senyap2 pon
terbalik pula dgn my parent in law, mmg x penah halang my hubby n sibling from reading comics.. and i tgk adik badik my hubby sume berjaya, in fact belajar oversea lagi

and, as for me as parent now, i pon rase i  akan buat cam tina
definitely not going to encourage, but also no to restrict them from reading
nak tgk dulu my children nanti mcm mana..if the comics doesn't effect them and their studies, i would definitely  let them read it once in a while
while my hubby lak, all comics yang dia simpan, such as dragon ball, juara bola keranjang (ini abah aku bg baca sbb citer sukan), budak getah, penyiasat remaja, conan (ni i my collection), etc..etc...ada 5 kotak besar..
my hubby mmg simpan utk anak2... but komik khayalan mcm dewa-dewa cina tuh, pedang setiawan, raja naga etc..yang tuh kitorg baca tapi pastu buang..atau sedekah kat kawan yang buat collection... sbb yg tuh x sesuai esp utk budak sekolah rendah

mieciput

Boleh. Mereka boleh baca apa2 juga komik. Tapi bahasa dia kena betul la. Kalau yg dapat kat pasaran tu semua bahasa berterabur. Tak tahu siapa agaknya yg translate. Sama gak kalau tengok sub title. That's why baik kalau baca apa2 buku pun dalam bahasa asalnya. kalau doraemon memang Jepun la. I yg buat translation skit2 ni, kadang2 terpingga2 kenapa la kerajaan kita lepaskan bahasa2 yg kelam kabut. tapi gaya nya adalah macam ni. Misalnya doraemon : Original Jepun --> Mandarin --> Melayu. Then org yg translatekan ke bahasa melayu ni bukan ada pengetahuan luas terhadap terjemahan. Ada yg buat direct translation tu yg parah. So tak salah kita belajar bahasa asing.

whitedove07

NEVER!kalo tak for sure BM asik failed je nanti.translation tunggalng langgang!

midori88

aku ok jer...komik nie semua kan sekadar hiburan shj..

gazelle

saya nanti anak dah besar..takkan marah kalo dia nak baca komik .  might join sekaki..)cuz i myself dulu  ade the whole doraemon siri hehehehhe... sampai bile dapat tau the artis meninggal sedih sebb to me, dia mmg creative giler .

besides doraemon...saya collect archie's comic. dulu dapat monthly allowance utk beli comic semua ni .

reading comic ade kebaikannye. my nephews, sekolah cina, so mmg ayah dia beli/sewa comic cina utk depa.

ps- masa pregnant, suka baca comic jepun Ranma. my husband kate my son jenis happy-go-lucky, bubbly, kelakar sbb mama dia tak pernah miss Ranma.

macademia

mmm.... anak mac yg suka doraemon tu, walaupun this yr start beriya2 baca doraemon, tapi alhamdullillah dia improve sangat2 in her BM. She even won the best student in BM for the whole of std 2.....

So i guess ok la kut.... ni pun dia tgh baca buku doraemon.... hehe

macademia

FYI, I have nothing against comic books... akan tetapi bila grammer BM or grammer english comic books itu bercelaru, itu yg buat mac risau bila anak2 membaca.

Delifrance

my younger cousin (pompuan) gila suka doraemon ni.... punya la byk buku doraemon ni dlm bilik dia, mesti complete set punya lah..

dulu terdetik jugak dlm hati i 'hek ena..apa punye buku laa budak ni baca..buang duit betoi!' .. sekali tgk spm dia straight As...mujur kutuk dlm hati kalau tak wat malu aje.. hahaha..

cikgutuition

Mac,

Saya dulu2 suka layan majalah Gila-Gila walaupun emak saya cukup x suka saya baca komik tu..Semua saya layan tapi kena tahule beza antara slang, informal words dan juga tatabahasa Bm yg betul n Alhamdulillah masa SPM dapat A jugak in BM..

ultraviolet

y not.
saya pun suka baca doraemon tu hehehhehehe
tapi kena supervise la sebab ada ayat dia yg tak enak

aiharanaoki

ok jeh..tp kena under supervision la walaopon apa yg dibacer..aku sampai skrg masih tak lekang dr komik crayon shin chan,detective conan.and channel animax is one of my favourites.

nurilham

ok ajer kot..tp kita kene monitor la....sbb bg saya....at scholl pun dah cukup serius dah apa yg dia belajar...semuanyer new thing yg dia kene adapt ....jadi bila ada masa senggang biar la dia enjoy dan relax.......tp kita always kene monitor...

dan satu bagusnyer...awal2 ilham warning kat depa....if mama notice you all terpengaruh dgn komik tu..definitely mama x bg baca lg....dan selalunyer they all akan refer pd ilham yg mana ok x ok....blh ke ma..buat mcm ni...mcm tu..ayatnyer salah ma..dan secara x lgsung....ilham akan ajar blk ayat yg sebetulnyer ....

dan ilham bg pun ..cuma on sabtu ahad jer .....3 jam tu they all blh baca komik apa yg they all nak.....dan main game apa yg meka nak ....ptg2 pegi la cycling ke apa ker

just release their mind jer...sbb masa ilham kecik2 pun....ilham mmg gila baca komik gila-gila tu..1 kepuasan kalau dpt baca magazine tu...dah baca tu...br blh fokus utk belajar....x der la ..kepala otak stuck kat study jer...my opinion jer...dan lain org mungkin lain caranyer...

ummiaiman

bagi saya ok jer asalkan mereka nak membaca tak kira apa juga bahan bacaan tapi bukan yang lucahlah.