Concept Of Reincarnation - Let's Debate :)

Sephiroth

Originally posted by wei_loon5063 at 8-5-2007 01:37 PM
rebirht in buddhism and reincarnation in hinduism is different..... bear in mind

This thread is about debating the concept of Reincarnation. Bear that in mind.

tickmeoff

he is sleeping now dude. you have to wait till morning time in UK for him to respond

wei_loon5063

Originally posted by Sephiroth at 9-5-2007 09:22 AM
This thread is about debating the concept of Reincarnation. Bear that in mind.

ok....... my fault.......

so, you want to debate that reincarnation is about the soul transfering from one body to anther??

Debmey

so what did rebirth transfer? Nothing? If nothing then why what for rebirth? Why not just birth?

wei_loon5063

rebirth?? Mass; matter and mind..........

this is reincarnation thread..... so its soul..........

Debmey

transfer of mass, matter, mind and soul?
mind is a subset of soul, how do you reconcile that?

wei_loon5063

mass, matter and mind in rebirth....

Soul in reincarnation....

Debmey

how did mass, mind and matter transfer in rebirth?

like i said, mind is a subset of soul. Besides, didn't you say that memories don't carry on from one life to the next, so how can the mind transfer under your system of rebirth? You seem to contradict and go wild even more every time you are questioned. Why?

Sephiroth

Originally posted by wei_loon5063 at 9-5-2007 02:26 PM

so, you want to debate that reincarnation is about the soul transfering from one body to anther??

Yes, Reincarnation is about Soul being transfered, or migrating from one body to another after Death of the pervious body.

Rebirth stated there is no Soul and that NOTHING survives after Death, YET something "born" by Rebirth. What is it? How can something be born if nothing from pervious existence survives?

If you say that the body get recycled, SO WHAT? Are you saying that you can "live" after you have died (physically)?
Rebirth is a foolish concept. Nothing in it make sense.