Stoning of She Monkey In Hadiths

Debmey

Exactly, it was made after Islam was established. It said 'I saw', it did not say I perceived then'.
What nonsense you are talking about?

And so the natural questions still remains up till now and are unanswered.

1. how did the sahabi know about the crime?
2. Did he talk to the monkeys?
3. Was he gifted enough with the ability of talking to animals?
4. Where was the he-monkey? Did it ran away, because after adultery whenever there is a possibility of punishment, running away with lightning speed is an eternal male culture.
5. Then, what should we understand by adultery of animals, birds, fish, etc.?

It all has to make sense in islam doesn't it? how can yu leave islam hanging in the air like that?

[ Last edited by Debmey on 9-4-2004 at 07:18 AM ]

if a female monkeys canot hav more than 1 mate, why hah male monkey can hav more than 1 mate? still the eagle more faithful lah! i mate for lifetime.... i support monogamy mah!

Debmey

Its natural that some animals, like monkeys are polygamous. There lies teh contradiction in islam.

Seraphim

One thing for sure..i know i'm aint a monkey because i dont follow monkeys as an example..

kyas

One thing for sure... it was during the pre-lslamic period of ignorance...

Debmey

But it was recorded as a fact duruing the islamic era, tahst one thing yu are trying to hard to deny.

MENJ

[quote]Originally posted by Debmey at 2004-4-2 10:08 AM:
Sah頷 al-Bukh鈘

MENJ

Originally posted by Debmey at 2004-4-9 10:16 AM:
Its natural that some animals, like monkeys are polygamous. There lies teh contradiction in islam.

It is natural that some morons, like Debmey, are just plain idiots. There lies the contradictio in Sino-Singaporean scums.

http://www.bismikaallahuma.org/Hadith/Exegesis/she-monkey.htm

- MENJ

Debmey

REbuttal of Menj's rebuttalis here. Lets all have a good laugh.

http://www.answering-islam.org/Responses/Menj/she-monkey.htm

MENJ

Originally posted by Debmey at 2004-4-12 01:17 PM:
REbuttal of Menj's rebuttalis here. Lets all have a good laugh.

http://www.answering-islam.org/Responses/Menj/she-monkey.htm

Yeah, I had a jolly good laugh at their "rebuttal" since nowhere does my article has anything to do with THEIR claims in the first place! So SFE has gone onto the path of morons and joined the AI team as well, predictable!

- MENJ

kid

Thanks MENJ... now all become clear there... go and read carefully Debmey befoer you make insult on Islam hurt their follower.

================
Conclusions

It is clear that where the had顃h regarding the stoning of a she-monkey for adultery is concerned, it is simply a recollection of a COMPANION of the Prophet (not prophet himself) regarding this maltreatment of animals during the pre-Islamic period of jah頻iyyah, which is in total contradiction to Islamic principles and norms.

Thus, the claim that this had顃h is the basis from which the lapidation for married adulterers in Islam came about is nothing more than a damp firecracker hurled by the haters and enemies of Islam. That their view of Islam had been tainted by deep ignorance, hatred, paranoia and xenophobia is no big secret, and this latest polemic is ipso facto a confirmation of their current condition.

And only God knows best.

===============================

[ Last edited by kid on 12-4-2004 at 01:24 PM ]

MENJ

Originally posted by kid at 2004-4-12 01:22 PM:
Thanks MENJ... now all become clear there... go and read carefully Debmey befoer you make insult on Islam hurt their follower.

No problem akhi, glad to be the "anti-virus" to the lies propagated by Debmey and his likes. I get my kicks from watching this idiot fumble after MENJ exposes him thoroughly. Isn't it interesting that his lies have been dealt with before? That hasn't seem to have changed.... ;););)

- MENJ

Debmey

hahahahahahaha................ sokid admits he has been bull all the time.

And menj has clearly been exposed for all to see.

cheers

MENJ

Originally posted by Debmey at 2004-4-12 01:43 PM:
hahahahahahaha................ sokid admits he has been bull all the time.

And menj has clearly been exposed for all to see.

cheers

http://www.menj.org/weblog/archives/000064.html

SFE is :spd:

- MENJ

Debmey

too bad yur blog has already been exposed good even before yu post.

MENJ

Originally posted by Debmey at 2004-4-12 02:02 PM:
too bad yur blog has already been exposed good even before yu post.

An example of a moron who can talk but has no brains....
lol:lol

SFE is  :spd:

- MENJ

Debmey

Is that all yu can say tio defend your writings? curse?

kid

Originally posted by Debmey at 12-4-2004 03:46 PM:
yeah! we have proven our case, the hadith is a joke and menj is lame. hahahahahahaha...........................

cheers

When we deliver the solid proof, the above "hahahahahaha" is the usual remark from this idiot.

He call other as joker, but he laugh at himself instead... he knew the clown is him.

FaithHealer3

Originally posted by kid at 2004-4-12 01:22 PM:
Conclusions

It is clear that where the had顃h regarding the stoning of a she-monkey for adultery is concerned, it is simply a recollection of a COMPANION of the Prophet (not prophet himself) regarding this maltreatment of animals during the pre-Islamic period of jah頻iyyah, which is in total contradiction to Islamic principles and norms.

:hmm:
Maltreatment of animal...
What about DOGS.
Why so much superstition abt dogs in Islam? Did Muhammad have give the order to kill dogs?

ref...
[quote]
From Sahih Muslim #5248

Debmey

And I have proven that the hadith is mad and Muslismlame.
kid definitely did not read the material i have provided as well as rebuttal of menj. I know he did not even read menj's defence for the hadith.